Fishers INN Islamorada Rooms Avg $189/Night

Found this place on a google search and scooped up a Black Friday special. Check-in was very efficient, a few simple items in the lobby if needed. Our room was clean and tidy. Nice look to the room and view was great. Everything has functioned as it should and very satisfied with our stay so far. A few amenities on site such as a boat launch, Cornhole, chairs in the sand and picnic tables. Have not had the chance to try the breakfast they offer but they do serve onsite just outside the man lobby. Staff in the lobby was prompt and polite to interact with.

Everything was fantastic. The rooms were very clean and smelled great. The outside was tidy and taken care of. The lobby staff were polite and thorough. Our AC was the only issue. It wouldn't keep up, and we would all wake up sweating every night. It was also the coldest day of the year! The mini-splits were still working double time.

We stayed at Fisher Inn Resort & Marina, and like any hotel, it has its pros and cons. I won’t focus on the negatives, as they have already been mentioned plenty of times in previous reviews. I’d rather share what we truly enjoyed. First of all, the staff is incredibly friendly. The young woman at the front desk deserves special thanks — she was absolutely wonderful. The young man was also very pleasant. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely willing to help. If you need anything, the staff really does their best to make your stay comfortable. The location is excellent. There is a beautiful park or botanical garden nearby, perfect for walking and relaxing. We stayed in a separate half of a cottage with direct access to the water and beach area. This beach is great for sunbathing, relaxing, or playing volleyball, but not ideal for swimming — which is quite typical for the Florida Keys and important to know in advance. A big advantage is that kayaks and bicycles are included in the stay, which adds a lot of value and makes the experience more enjoyable without extra costs. One bonus that pleasantly surprised us was the complimentary access to a wonderful nearby park with a real swimming beach. It’s especially perfect for children: the water is shallow, safe, and gradually gets deeper. Admission is free for hotel guests. The park is only about a 6-minute drive from the hotel and offers free parking. If the hotel invested a bit more in island-style décor — in the bedrooms, bathrooms, and breakfast area — and offered hot breakfasts such as eggs, bacon, and more toasters, this place could easily reach a very high level. I truly believe such investments would pay off many times over. Overall, this is a lovely place, especially for families with children. We were very happy with our stay. Many thanks to the entire hotel team for the warm welcome and excellent hospitality.

Nice amenities and great staff. The rooms are generously sized and they are being renovated and updated. The king sized beds are very comfortable - firm yet not too hard wi th nice crisp linens and nice pillows. The best part is the private beach, free paddle boards, kayaks, and bikes. We have used these amenities daily and they are awesome!

Lovely renovation.. room was beautiful but too pricey for motel like place. For a bit more you can stay at a luxury resort with a true beach view, restaurants, bars, nicer pool(s) and not mangroves in front of your room off a fishing walkway.. Staff was extemely friendly and efficient especially front desk. Clean, clean, clean.. very well kept. Would recommend if you want to pay the high price and stay in motel like place. Access to beach is nice, great chairs and tiki shade cabanas and good fishing right out front.